Pete, I agree with your doctrinal statement except for your ‘kept saved forever’ statement. I believe scripture teaches us we CAN be kept saved forever, but just as God does not force himself on man to become saved, in the same manner, he does not force man to remain saved.
Paul writes to Timothy this;
1 Timothy 4:1 (KJV) Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils; Man can choose to depart from the faith (which I see no other explanation other than they are/were saved) or choose to remain faithful. In summary, Scriptures teach us both eternal security (God keeps us so no outside entity can take our faith away) AND free will (we choose to accept and cling to Christ, and also to forsake and let him go). We are wise to understand both.
I have often struggled with this topic - one side says if you continue to struggle in or are in bondage to a sin you might never had been saved. The other other side says you could loose your salvation..
Sanctification is a process. Even Paul in Romans 7 appeared to struggle. Then in Romans 8 offered the solution of walking in the Spirit which is something we learn to do by greater dependence on the Holy Spirit rather than our own resources
One might wonder if one is saved if they struggle greatly with some sins of Galatians 5:19-21 and are slow to develop the fruit of Galatians 5:22-23. I have often thought our Salvation is secure if we abide in him according to John 15:4
Did the prodigal son abide? No he rejected his father and abused his inheritance in great sin. He repented and return to his father who forgive him, put a ring on his finger and restored the relationship but if he had stayed in the pig pen would he have been lost?
If we go ahead and assume that it is possible for us to relinquish our salvation through an act of our free will this then creates a logical problem.
The state of the world as it is was created by Man saying that he would rather follow Man’s will than follow God's Will. Because Man was made lesser than God, Man is incapable, because he was not designed that way, to do the job that God has which is to do what is best for God's creation and what is best for us. Man lacks the ability to see perfectly the consequences of his actions. This is why God's Will must be in charge.
Any "work" that Man does to attain or keep his own salvation therefore recommits the sin that caused the break between God and Man.
The only "work" that you can do, and that is a necessary exercise of your free will is to "believe in Him whom He sent".
28Then they said to Him, “What shall we do, that we may work the works of God?”
29Jesus answered and said to them, “This is the work of God, that you believe in Him whom He sent.”
John 6:28-29
After you have done that you are no longer in charge of maintaining your salvation. If you were in charge of maintaining your salvation you would fail. We would all fail. Maintaining our salvation by constantly repressing our free will and our desire to do according to our own will is a "work" outside of the requirement that Jesus described.
God's Will must be in charge. After we accept our salvation, it is.
Agreed, however, if we are sealed by the Holy Spirit until the day of redemption as Paul sated in Ephesians 4:30 (I too believe this is true for the born again), in that same verse we are warned to not grieve the Holy Spirit. I guess the real question is, how does one do that? We do know what Jesus himself said in Matthew 12:31.
It’s not about forcing anyone to remain saved, it’s about fundamentally transforming one’s nature from spiritually dead, to spiritually alive. It’s about becoming a new creation, the old is gone away. And just as one cannot earn salvation by works, one cannot un-earn it by works either. There are only two paths for those who are truly born again and turn away- either they are brought back (prodigal son style) or they’re taken home. Lastly though, just because someone walks an aisle or makes a profession of faith doesn’t make them born again. That is ultimately between that person and God. All I know is that once you’re born again, you are sealed by the Holy Spirit until the day of Redemption.